Forex Zone - Forex Forum

Classical Technical Analysis Using Dow Theory in Technical_67f83ac065b44

Classical Technical Analysis Using Dow Theory

Discussion started on Technical

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 104
  • Points: 0
  • Likes Received: 4
  • Reputation: +0/-0
slowly sir .. is the criterion of a valid volume index? What does it mean is there a definite count for this volume ... for disvergence and its convergence ... if there is a value, sir ... previously posted an example chart not taken from the metatrader, can it be applied in the MetaRetrer pack, considering that in the meta there is also an index volume ... to get a small TF from the chart above, where are you?
The volume in MT4 cannot be used, the explanation already exists in the initial post about volume. For platforms that have real volume, please download it here, but only 2 weeks free for the trial http://www.cmegroup.com/market-data/.../overview.html
#31 - February 23, 2019, 01:11:46 PM
« Last Edit: February 24, 2019, 02:58:49 AM by Mochammad Rendy Setiawan »

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 104
  • Points: 0
  • Likes Received: 4
  • Reputation: +0/-0
Examples of reversal applications and the start of new trends on real charts, explanations and illustrations see post # 40

Quote
Spoiler title=SpoilerSpoiler:
Classical Technical Analysis Using Dow Theory in Technical_proxy




Trends and corrections.

If a correction occurs far enough to be able to form a lower Low more than once (on the up trend), then it can be helped by a fibonachi retracement to detect whether the price is only a correction or continues until a trend changes, or it can also use the elliot wave (I don't understand how to use elliot wave)


Quote
Spoiler title=SpoilerSpoiler:
Classical Technical Analysis Using Dow Theory in Technical_proxy

#32 - February 23, 2019, 01:13:39 PM

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 110
  • Points: 0
  • Likes Received: 8
  • Reputation: +0/-0
Volume di MT4 tidak bisa digunakan, penjelasannya sudah ada di posting awal tentang volume. Utk platform yg ada real volume silahkan download di sini, tetapi cuman free 2 minggu utk trial http://www.cmegroup.com/market-data/.../overview.html
what I was looking for and made me curious finally answered here clearly ... that is some of the factors that caused a new reaction high (low reaction) ... fear (fear), hope (hope) and expectations of all traders or unexpected events, such as natural disasters, selling because prices have been considered high and the profits they have felt are enough ... like the Om Kito post above ... all this time I know it's only that every move the price of up / down will definitely interspersed with correction movements ... without understanding more in ... one more thing is understanding convergence and divergence ... for charts on MT4 can it use RSI to measure convergence and divergence combined with the motion of the price sir ... so I had time to study the RSI ... so far 80% is valid on the M15 TF and H1 Thank you sir ... I'm waiting for the update of the material ...
#33 - February 23, 2019, 01:14:30 PM

Sponsored

Classical Technical Analysis Using Dow Theory in Technical_6803a6c52eb12
#34 - Today at 06:01:42 PM

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 104
  • Points: 0
  • Likes Received: 4
  • Reputation: +0/-0
what I was looking for and made me curious finally answered here clearly ... that is some of the factors that caused a new reaction high (low reaction) ... fear (fear), hope (hope) and expectations of all traders or unexpected events, such as natural disasters, selling because prices have been considered high and the profits they have felt are enough ... like the Om Kito post above ... all this time I know it's only that every move the price of up / down will definitely interspersed with correction movements ... without understanding more in ... one more thing is understanding convergence and divergence ... for charts on MT4 can it use RSI to measure convergence and divergence combined with the motion of the price sir ... so I had time to study the RSI ... so far 80% is valid on the M15 TF and H1 Thank you sir ... I'm waiting for the update of the material ...
Convergence and divergence in this technique are between price movements with volume, if the RSI in MT4 if I am not mistaken, between the price and the price itself, it is certainly different.
#34 - February 23, 2019, 01:15:46 PM

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 104
  • Points: 0
  • Likes Received: 4
  • Reputation: +0/-0
Support - Resistance

There are several ways to determine support and resistance levels. In theory Dow levels of HH and LL also become support and resistance levels.

- Higher High level as Support and Resistance

When the price corrects down (on the up trend) after previously forming a new Higher High (HH) level, then after the correction is complete, the price will move up again. When the price rises again from this correction it will face resistance, where the resistance is the level of the newly formed HH.

When the HH level which also functions as the above resistance can be broken, then the price will return to the new HH level again, after that, on a patron basis, the price will return to correction. When this correction, then the HH level that has been broken before, will be a support level.

To be clearer, consider the example in the chart below.

Quote
Spoiler title=SpoilerSpoiler:
Classical Technical Analysis Using Dow Theory in Technical_proxy


For Down Trends, the principle is the same as identification of support - resistance on the up trend above, the difference is that on the up trend which is a support level - resistance is the HH level, then down trend is the LL level.

In addition, you can also use trend lines, channels, supply-demand balance areas etc.
#35 - February 24, 2019, 02:29:10 AM

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 104
  • Points: 0
  • Likes Received: 4
  • Reputation: +0/-0
Buy and Sell Entry

There are 2 types of traders in entry decision making, aggressive and moderate. Aggressive types are more willing to take risks, but with the magnitude of the risk they face will get opportunities to gain or greater reward opportunities. While moderate types are usually more patient and very careful, taking into account the risks so that they can be reduced as small as possible, because they are very considerate of risk, then the opportunity to get a gain or the opportunity to get a reward is smaller than the aggressive type.

Entry point illustration

Quote
Spoiler title=SpoilerSpoiler:
Classical Technical Analysis Using Dow Theory in Technical_proxy


Image of entry point in real market

Quote
Spoiler title=SpoilerSpoiler:
Classical Technical Analysis Using Dow Theory in Technical_proxy


Target loss: around 20 pips below support to buy positions on up trend and 20 pips above resistance to sell positions on down trend

TP target: around 20 pips below resistance to buy position or 20 pips above support to sell position.

The references to TP and SL above are not rigid, it can also be used as a percentage of TP targets, or a percentage of price movement averages (price movement range, daily / weekly / monthly). adapted to trading style. About 20 to 30% of the monthly average movement range for long terms, 20 to 30% of the weekly average movement for swing and 20 to 30% of the daily moving average. Whereas TP can be set with 80% of the monthly, weekly or daily movements for long term, swing and intraday.
#36 - February 24, 2019, 02:30:53 AM

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 104
  • Points: 0
  • Likes Received: 4
  • Reputation: +0/-0
A Little About Candle Formation vs. Peak and Through At Dow Teory

Flag formation candle


Quote
Spoiler title=SpoilerSpoiler:
Classical Technical Analysis Using Dow Theory in Technical_proxy


In the picture above it can be seen, the formation of a flag formation candle because the price has formed Peak or Higher High and Through or Higher Low on the up trend in the Dow Theory, thus it can be understood that the opportunity to break up penetrates the line resistance in the flag formation, it has a greater chance because of the price movement up the trend. Likewise for inverted flag formation, the opportunity to penetrate the support line in the inverted flag formation has a greater chance, because prices are moving in a down trend


Inverted Head and Sholder

Quote
Spoiler title=SpoilerSpoiler:
Classical Technical Analysis Using Dow Theory in Technical_proxy



From the picture above, it can be seen, the head and sholder are formed, because the initial change in the trend from the bottom changes to an up trend. When there will be a change from down to up, the price cannot break the last lower low, this condition makes the head inverted head and sholder formed. Before that, on the previous downtrend movement, it has already formed left sholder, then when the price is unable to break the last lower low and continues to break lower high, this condition forms the right sholder.

Furthermore, because it has been indicated that there will be a trend change, then the nickline has a high chance of being broken, as well as when it has been broken, then when the price pulls back towards the nickline, there is a large opportunity to bounce because at the same time it also faces a lower high that has been broken.
#37 - February 24, 2019, 02:32:18 AM

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 104
  • Points: 0
  • Likes Received: 4
  • Reputation: +0/-0
Conclusion

1. Cycle of a trend through each of the 3 phases up trend and 3 phases of down trend, these phases are:

- Up Trend: Accumulation - Participation - Distribution
- Down Trend: Distribution - Participation - Accumulation

After the trend completes the cycle, it will usually be continued with the next cycle.

2. Prices are said to move in:
- Up trend if, the price is always able to break higher high and form a new higher high, followed by Low higher than previous Low (Higher Low / HL)

- Down Trend if, the price is always able to break lower low and form a new lower low, followed by a high lower than the previous high (Lower High / LH)

3. Reversal
- On up trend: If the price cannot break a higher high and instead breaks down the low higer after that followed by a pullback / retest move to the broken higher low and then bounces.

- On the down trend: If the price is unable to break lower low and instead breaks above the lower high after that followed by a pullback / retest motion to the broken lower high and then bounces.

4. Trend continuity must be confirmed by volume. But the trend is not determined by volume.

5. In the stock market, volume can work effectively, because the stock market is 100% centralized. Unlike the forex market which is not 100% centralized. Thus the volume of currency trading is not fully recorded, except in the futures forex market. However, because the transactions in the forex futures market are multinational companies, banking institutions and large traders, the transactions that occur in the futures market are very influential on the overall price movements of the currency, because even though sometimes it is a bit biased, it can still be used as an analysis tool.

6. Entry follows the current trend at the lowest on the daily TF with the following rules.
- In market moving up trend conditions: For Aggressive type, when the higher high break and clipping prices are above the higher high, then the entry is made at the next open candle. For the moderate type, the entry is made when the price pulls back to the higher high that is broken.

- In market down trend conditions: For Aggressive type, when the price breaks lower low and closes below the lower low, then the entry is done at the open candle the next day. For the moderate type, the entry is done when the price pullback to the lower low breaks.

By posting this conclusion, the Classic Technical Analysis material using the Dow Theory is complete. Next we continue with questions about the material that has been posted. I beg before asking, patiently read all the material that has been delivered. Ask questions related to the material, and if you have been asked, please do not ask again.
#38 - February 24, 2019, 02:33:59 AM

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 104
  • Points: 0
  • Likes Received: 4
  • Reputation: +0/-0
In theory, the volume is used to confirm the trend. The rule according to Dow is: In the upward movement, it must be supported by an increase in volume. Similarly, in the downward movement, it must be confirmed by a decrease in volume.

The problem is, in fact, the theory is not always directly in line with the facts in the market, when prices move linearly, volume movements often fluctuate, not the Dow theory is wrong, but Dow conducted the research in a centralized market index stock, and every transaction that occurred was all recorded, so the volume data became valid and even then it was predicted more than a century ago, which could not necessarily match 100% with the current conditions.

While the characters in the forex market are different from the stock market. The nature of trading in a centralized currency makes transactions spread in many places around the world, starting from transactions that occur in banks to money changers, even in web money such as LR etc. Spot currency transactions in all parts of the world, there is no volume record, therefore if we use volume data on the spot forex market there will be a difference in its validity with the volume on the stock market.

However, as with previous posts, I referred a lot of this volume data to the commodity futures market on the Chicago Mercentile Exchange. One of the commodities traded on the exchange is the currency. Currency trading on futures exchanges includes accommodating the needs of the commercial sector to hedge. In general, product trade, both the products produced by manufacturing and processed products, are carried out in a forward manner, the contracts carried out today will only be sent in the future within a certain period of time, with prices determined according to the agreement. The time gap when a contract is dealt with the time the product is delivered, opens opportunities for uncertainty about changes, both changes in the value or price of the product itself and the value of the currency. Thus there is a potential risk for possible changes in product prices and the value of the currency in the future. If the change is a decrease in the value of both the product price and the value of the currency, then the supplier or producer will experience losses due to a decline in price and value, conversely if there is an increase, then the buyer or consumer who will suffer losses. This condition encourages the commercial sector to enter the cash / currency futures market to hedge against future uncertainties. Including the banking sector which is participating in transactions in the currency futures market in the context of financial transactions (credit transactions etc.) between banks globally.

The value of money transacted in the currency futures market is certainly very large, because it is carried out by companies both small companies and large giant class companies all over the world plus all commercial banks. Then in addition to the hedging commercial sector, which is involved in the transaction in the currency futures market, large traders aiming at speculation (profit taking) utilize the supply and demand that occur because of the needs of the commercial sector. The amount of transaction value that occurs in the currency futures market, will affect the movement of currency values, as a whole, thus the recorded volume can be an analytical material to measure the power of supply and demand on the currency in the currency futures market, where the imbalance of supply and demand will affect the movement of currency values.

The problem is that fluctuations in volume movements are not parallel to fluctuations in price movements, however, they are still useful as a means of confirming price movements, in order to reduce the error of this analysis, the method is done by looking at divergence and convergence between the price and volume. When generally between price movements and volume movements are still convergence, then there will not be a change in the direction of price movements, when divergence has occurred, then the direction of price movements will change.

But keep in mind, that this volume must be placed as a confirmation tool, the main one is the pattern of price movements on the chart itself, as long as price movements still meet the HH - HL criteria for up trend and LL - LH for down trend, we must use this as the main reference in making trading decisions, do not be reversed so that they are not biased. When the price has begun to move it does not match these criteria, in the changes that occur in the first candle that we confirm with the volume, if it turns out the volume shows divergence then the indication will
#39 - February 24, 2019, 02:35:57 AM

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 104
  • Points: 0
  • Likes Received: 4
  • Reputation: +0/-0
The Kalisk Technical Analysis Application Uses the Dow Theory

1. Analyze GBPUSD

As a learning material for applying this technique, I will start by making an analysis starting from TF Monthly Trend Major.


Quote
Spoiler title=SpoilerSpoiler:
Classical Technical Analysis Using Dow Theory in Technical_proxy



In the GU image above, after the excess cycle is complete, the price is distributed in one phase until it touches the lowest level around 1.42xx without going through the phase of participation and excess.

Now at the major trend, GU is starting to show efforts to recover and is currently in the phase of accumulation. In this accumulation phase GU looks after trying to get up and forming LH and then pulls back the retest Lower Low (LL) but the amount of demand has pushed GU back up before reaching Lower Low (LL) and then a higher Low is formed (Higher Low / HL ) This formation, according to Dow rules, the price will try to break Lower High (LH). If it is able to be skipped it will form a High higher than the previous high (LH) and the major trend will continue with a bullish move entering the participation phase.

To see the next possibility, we try to observe the movements in TF weekly and daily as Midle Trend as follows:

TF Weekly

Quote
Spoiler title=SpoilerSpoiler:
Classical Technical Analysis Using Dow Theory in Technical_proxy


#40 - February 24, 2019, 02:38:43 AM

Sponsored

#41 - Today at 06:01:42 PM

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 104
  • Points: 0
  • Likes Received: 4
  • Reputation: +0/-0
At TF weekly it seems before the formation of an up trend with a series of HH-HLs, but a little restrained when going through a higher high and prices moving in a range or flat for several weeks until finally being able to get out of that range was even able to close above higher high thus GU opportunities are very large at this major trend to continue to rise to create new higher hihger highs. However, because it is on TF weekly, to complete 1 candle in this TF, there will be five candles on the daily TF, and it is possible that in the 5 candles there will be an up and down movement. To find the best opportunity, I will enter the daily TF as follows:

TF Daily

Quote
Spoiler title=SpoilerSpoiler:
Classical Technical Analysis Using Dow Theory in Technical_proxy


#41 - February 24, 2019, 02:52:53 AM

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 104
  • Points: 0
  • Likes Received: 4
  • Reputation: +0/-0
In the daily TF above, GU has been moving for quite a long time in the channel line which tends to go up. And yesterday the price broke the high level before finally closing below the high level and at the upper side of the channel line. Because at the major trend TF monthly GU is in the accumulation phase of the up trend, and in the middle trend TF weekly the price is able to break and close above the higher high, so the opportunity to continue going up on TF weekly is very large. If GU on Monday continues to rise and closes above a higher high, then aggressive types on Tuesday can enter by taking long positions. For those who are moderate, they need to be patient, waiting for prices to pull back to the Higher High area at this time.

Or if you want to be more aggressive, you can enter to take momentum after the Higher High break level of 1.6430 on TF H4, and put a stop loss around 20-30 pips below the higher high level. But if the price has not yet broken the HH level, postpone the position first, until the price is able to break with the clossing candle on it. See picture GU TF H4 below


Quote
Spoiler title=SpoilerSpoiler:
Classical Technical Analysis Using Dow Theory in Technical_proxy



#42 - February 24, 2019, 02:53:21 AM

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 104
  • Points: 0
  • Likes Received: 4
  • Reputation: +0/-0
Open the position below as a learning material, not used as a trading signal.

As a result of the analysis in the GU pair which concludes that the buy option is the choice where the steps of analysis are in post # 72. I entered buy when the price touched the Higher Higher level before. The entry that I did was classified as very aggressive, but of course I did this also by taking into account the risks that psychologically I could receive, which was 50 pips. It is exactly 10 pips below the support level on the H4 TF. However besides the expected profit opportunities, of course there are risks that accompany, the important thing is how we can minimize these risks by limiting losses that might occur.


Quote
Spoiler title=SpoilerSpoiler:
Classical Technical Analysis Using Dow Theory in Technical_proxy

#43 - February 24, 2019, 02:58:03 AM

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 104
  • Points: 0
  • Likes Received: 4
  • Reputation: +0/-0
After Friday, the EU reached the highest price since 2010 at 1.4487, on Monday the EU lost momentum to move even higher, then prices corrected. Seeing the weak momentum confirmed by the decline in volume on the EU Globex (currency future), it may be that the 1.4487 level is a higher high level for the EU to have a chance to move further to form a higher low (HL). A safe option is the entry when the price has completed the correction, and enter the market in accordance with the direction of the trend.

If on GU yesterday I used a demo account as a learning for intraday trading. Then the position seen on the MT4 chart below is a position on the real account, and the previous 2 buy positions I have hedged (lock) with 1 sell position and I will open it when the correction is complete. Support levels that will be a concern to see the possibility of a reversal as an indication of completion of the correction is 1.4350 (HH in TF H4) and 1.4240 (HH on daily TF) and confirmed by the volume movement at Euro Globex on the CME commodity exchange.


EU/USD MT4
Quote
Spoiler title=SpoilerSpoiler:
Classical Technical Analysis Using Dow Theory in Technical_proxy


EURO Globex TF Daily
Quote
Spoiler title=SpoilerSpoiler:
Classical Technical Analysis Using Dow Theory in Technical_proxy

#44 - February 24, 2019, 03:02:59 AM

Members:

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.



Elementor Wordpress Hosting